Acid/Base Theory

We chemists have three acid/base theories or definitions to help us conceptualize what we categorize as acid/base reactions. I will summarize each of them briefly.

1. Arrhenius Theory

Arrhenius theory is the oldest and most limiting definition:

  • an acid is something that when dissolved in water, results in the production of H+ ions
  • a base is something that when dissolved in water, results in the production of OH ions

2. Lowry/Bronsted Theory

Lowry/Bronsted is what we mostly use in intro and general chemistry classes. It is a broader definition. It is based on a specific donor/acceptor model:

  • an acid is a proton (H+) donor
  • a base is a proton (H+) acceptor

3. Lewis Theory

Lewis theory is the broadest of definitions of all theories and is particularly useful/popular with organic chemists and various organic reaction types. It too is a donor/acceptor model:

  • an acid is an electron pair acceptor
  • a base is an electron pair donor

Which one do we use?

We will tend to use the Lowry/Bronsted (L/B) definition as our definition. Realize that it covers everything that Arrhenius covers - meaning the same acids and bases in Arrhenius theory are also acids and bases in L/B theory. It's just that the L/B definition covers a few more cases - especially organic amines as weak bases because they accept protons from water. They themselves do not provide the hydroxide to make a base, but they do provide the proton acceptor to accept a proton from water, thus leaving behind a hydroxide which will raise the pH of the solution just like any base would.

So in the most generic way of showing a L/B acid-base reaction,

Notice how in this generic case, the two starting reactants are both neutral in charge (zero charge). After a H+ jumps ship off the acid and onto the base, the result are two ions - a cation (former neutral base) and an anion (former neutral acid). Without all the circles and colors, this would be shown like this:

And now lets write an actual real reaction with acetic acid (CH3COOH) playing the role of acid (HA) and good ol' water, H2O, playing the role of base (B).

previous back to top next

© 2019-2023 · mccord